Thunderdome

« Back to the top page
Paul Boutin

The media's fake Twitter backlash begins

Paul Boutin, The Industry Standard04.17.2009
Tags
Comments 8
twitter_fail_whale.JPG
Like the story? Get Alerts of big news events. Enter your email address

If you've been waiting for the inevitable Twitter backlash, the fun starts now. Sure, CNN ran an "is there a Twitter backlash?" story last month. But for those of us who work in the media, we knew the question mark in the headline meant the answer was "No."

Today, as Oprah tweets on TV, the New York Observer made it official: "The backlash begins." You don't read the Observer, but every status-obsessed journalist in Manhattan does. It's now officially cool to do a Twitter Backlash story.

Here's how it works:

  1. The Observer says there's a backlash.
  2. A Gartner analyst uses the article to say there's a media backlash to Twitter. He's right: It's in the Observer, which means that it will be repeated by the most trend-conscious journalists all over Manhattan. Didn't you know about the Twitter backlash? It was in the Observer.
  3. Many of those journalists will now quote Gartner, a widely respected technology analyst firm, that there's a Twitter backlash.
  4. The backlash topic will become a hot Twitter topic: #backlash
  5. Didn't you know there's a Twitter backlash? It's all over Twitter.

The real winner? CNN, who will claim to have broken the story. 


More news, commentary, and predictions from The Industry Standard:


Comments

This is a brilliant prediction! It will be entertaining to see it play out and then cite this article.

Unfortunately, it's also possible that the media's awareness of this article actually keeps it from happening, which would be a shame...


what is twitter?


SOL! (Snort Out Loud)


WaySouth Media, Inc. to acquire Twitter. But not until I lose 10 lbs.


See the blog entry I wrote at http://blog.robdolin.com/ that provides an intro to Twitter.


The real "winner" is the media, who's terrified of #UPI2.0 - whenever legacy media does a "helpful" story about the ills/dangers of Web 2.0, realize they are FAR from being impartial. We're talking about major disintermediation here. Media will have to go up the value chain or continue to lose readers with alacrity; the big opportunity for them is to pair their unique competencies with all of us. We are everythere, and they need to tap us in a transparent, honest way.


This was how I felt when, early in the election propaganda, someone said "Barack Obama is too young and inexperienced." Before long, everyone was repeating the same garbage. Glad we overcame that one.

Same thing about Sarah Palin being "more experienced."
It's laughable, but people will believe anything if they hear it over and over again...

"Diet Coke will help you lose weight" is another favorite "repeat it until they believe it" phrase.


I would like to see Twitter filter/block all major media outlets from using their services, much like ;old media' did to their news wires. ;)


Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Respectful debate is welcome, but comments that are defamatory, indecent, abusive, or in violation of any law will be removed.