« Back to the top page
IDG News Service

The iCal challenge

William Porter, Macworld08.07.2008
Tags
Comments 2
Like the story? Get Alerts of big news events. Enter your email address

SOHO Organizer's creators felt that they could ask a calendar to do even more. As a calendar, its advantages over iCal may seem minor. SOHO Organizer provides some customized printing options that iCal lacks. The calendar in SOHO Organizer supports a variety of international calendar types; in addition to the standard Gregorian calendar, SOHO Organizer also supports Buddhist, Hebrew, and Islamic calendar formats. And SOHO Organizer's calendar has more display options than iCal has. But you have to step outside the calendar grid to see the most compelling advantages of SOHO Organizer. In an office environment, both iCal and SOHO Organizer calendars can be shared among users, but SOHO Organizer has been designed with more thought to multiuser access.

SOHO Organizer's strength lies principally in the interoperability of its calendar, address book, and SOHO Notes. The SOHO Organizer contacts screen lets you see all events (appointments and tasks) associated with a particular contact, although in iCal you can quickly search the calendar by attendee name to get a similar result. But the real power of SOHO Organizer is the way it works with SOHO Notes. SOHO Organizer provides two ways to write lengthy, free-form memos tied to specific days: the daily journal and daily notes. It seems like one or the other of these could be jettisoned, but Chronos seems to expect that you'll record things like your expenses in the daily notes, and use the journal for more expansive entries. If you're a note-writing kind of person, then the SOHO Organizer suite might be just your thing.

If you're looking for a calendar that's both multiuser and cross-platform, check out Now Software's Now Up-to-Date & Contact, two programs that come as a package. Now Up-to-Date & Contact is basically a souped-up combination of Apple's Address Book and iCal that you can easily share on a network. Unfortunately, Now Up-to-Date & Contact is showing its age. Now Software has been working on a replacement called Nighthawk, which is still in beta at this writing.

Daylite cuts through the clutter with an organizer that combines the power of several programs into one tool.Another homely but capable calendar comes from the open-source folks at Mozilla. Sunbird is pretty basic, and on the Mac, most folks will probably be happier with iCal or another choice. Sunbird can't connect with other Mac programs and services such as Address Book or MobileMe. Sunbird's notifications are limited to on-screen pop-ups, and you can only set one. But Sunbird has one nice trick. It supports add-ons, and if you install the free Provider For Google Calendar add-on, you'll be able to get to your Google calendar from Sunbird, and vice versa; you can then manage your calendars equally well from any location. Also, like iCal, Sunbird is free.

Web-Based Services

If you don't want--or can't afford--to be tied to a single operating system or computer, then you can access similar calendar and organizer functions via your browser with Google and Yahoo calendars. These are most similar to the calendars in iCal, SOHO Organizer, and Sunbird. Both of these online calendars allow you to create multiple calendars, invite guests, and receive notifications.

For people who work on multiple machines, the ability to access your e-mail and calendar from any Internet-connected device makes the online services irresistible. Yahoo's calendar includes a basic to-do list and notetaking feature not found in Google's calendar. Nonetheless, I prefer Google Calendar because I use Google Gmail for my e-mail. Gmail can often recognize that an e-mail message is suggesting an appointment and will offer a quick way to create an event in your calendar. iCal can do something similar, but in iCal you have to hold your mouse over that text. Google Calendar lets you manage multiple color-coded calendars directly from your browser.

Gmail's feature is a bit smarter. I sent myself a test message, inviting myself to a meeting tomorrow, perhaps


Comments

What ToDo as your GTD app of choice? Seriously?

OmniFocus offers so much more - full GTD geekiness, and it syncs over the air with the OmniFocus iPhone app so you always have your tasks with you when you're in various contexts. It also syncs tasks into iCal (splitting different contexts' actions into different iCal calendars if you'd like). Over all an amazing task manager for the GTD crowd.


You do realize that Gmail is not void of to-do lists? All it takes is one Remember the Milk Firefox extension and viola, you've got a task manager. I also love GTDinbox in Gmail, although I don't use Gmail as a task management tool.

For task management, Omnifocus is the best out there. Things is the closest competitor, but I'll always pick hierarchial views over tagging. That's why I don't use Remember the Milk anymore, which is another awesome task manager.

Small business owners need the right tools for the job, and Daylite just isn't completely there as a task manager. I use it to manage my relationships with contacts, prospects, clients, etc. E-mail messages, notes regarding communications, contact info, major completed tasks and projects, appointments (regarding contacts), and all organizations go into Daylite. I don't manage projects and tasks in Daylite; I just record them after completion, and only if they are related to a particular contact. That may change when the iPhone app comes out, assuming that some improvements are made with how Daylite desktop manages tasks. Until then, Daylite is great for business reference and contact management.

My calendar of choice is definitely Apple iCal. I sync it with my iPhone (because MobileMe sucks and free Exchange alternatives aren't great, either), and I also sync it with Google calendar and Daylite. I definitely think more thought went into iCal then Apple Mail, which I tolerate because of it's great integration with Leopard and my other applications. Gmail is still my favorite email client.

Here's the system I'm working with:

1) Daylite to manage relationships with contacts and organizations.
2) Omnifocus to manage projects and tasks.
3) Evernote to keep reference material that is not directly related to a contact (that's Daylite turf).
4) iCal to manage all of my calendars in sync with Gcal.
5) Apple Mail to manage my email in conjunction with Gmail.
6) Omnioutliner to make decisions and plans.

The only part of my system that isn't in the palm of my hand is Daylite, which should appear on the iPhone in January of 2009.

The best software for the job is the one that gets along best with your habits and your other apps, and everything works with iCal. It's more of an iCal cooperation than a challenge, and there are constantly new improvements that make it easier to get things done.